Mood Choice in Complements
In Hungarian, subordinate clauses starting with hogy (that) require either the indicative or subjunctive mood depending on the meaning of the main verb.
How It Works
Hungarian divides that-clauses into three categories based on the semantic intent of the clause. While some versatile verbs can take multiple moods depending on meaning, many matrix verbs strictly require a specific mood:
1. The Indicative Mood
Used for asserted, factual, or epistemically evaluated events. This often follows verbs of saying, knowing, seeing, and believing.
- Látom, hogy jön. (I see that he is coming.)
2. The Subjunctive Mood
Used for non-factual, desired, commanded, or purpose-driven events. This follows verbs of ordering, wishing, requesting, permitting, and purpose clauses. The subjunctive is formed using the -j suffix. It is morphologically identical to the imperative mood, meaning there is no separate subjunctive conjugation table. This suffix often triggers sibilant assimilation as well as complex changes with verbs ending in -t.
- Akarom, hogy jöjjön. (I want him to come.)
Preverb Placement and Negative Clauses
Because the imperative and subjunctive are morphologically identical, Hungarian distinguishes them syntactically through the placement of the verbal prefix. For indirect commands or requests, the prefix splits and moves after the verb (e.g., Azt mondta, hogy menjek el. 'He told me to leave.'). For purpose clauses, wishes, or evaluations, the prefix stays attached to the front of the verb (e.g., Fontos, hogy elmenjek. 'It is important that I leave.'). Additionally, for negative purpose clauses, Hungarian uses nehogy or hogy ne. While nehogy prevents preverb splitting (e.g., Siess, nehogy lekéssük a vonatot. 'Hurry, lest we miss the train.'), using hogy ne acts as standard negation and forces the preverb to split (e.g., Siess, hogy ne késsük le a vonatot.).
3. The Conditional Mood
Used for hypothetical events, polite requests, or sometimes after negated verbs of belief or doubt. The conditional is formed using the -na/-ne/-ná/-né suffixes.
- Nem hiszem, hogy eljönne. (I don't believe he would come.)
Indirect Questions
To form indirect questions (equivalent to 'if' or 'whether'), Hungarian attaches the interrogative particle -e to the verb in the subordinate clause. Note that in standard prescriptive grammar, combining hogy and -e in the same clause is considered a pleonasm, so hogy is typically omitted: Nem tudom, eljön-e. (I don't know whether he will come.)
Anticipatory Pronouns (Utalószó)
A defining syntactic feature of Hungarian complement clauses is the frequent use of an anticipatory demonstrative pronoun (such as azt, arra, ahhoz) in the main clause that points forward to the hogy clause. For example: Azt akarom, hogy jöjjön. (I want [that] that he comes.)
Meaning Shifts
Many verbs can take different moods, which fundamentally changes their meaning. For example, mond (say) + indicative means 'to state a fact', whereas mond + subjunctive means 'to give a command'.
Important Distinctions
Unlike English, which uses infinitives for different-subject commands (e.g., 'I want him to go'), Hungarian requires hogy + subjunctive. However, for same-subject desires, Hungarian uses the infinitive (e.g., El akarok menni. 'I want to go.'). Furthermore, unlike Romance languages, Hungarian uses the indicative or conditional for verbs of emotion, hope, and doubt (e.g., remél 'hope' takes the indicative). Crucially, the subjunctive mood has no past tense in modern Hungarian. Even if the main verb is in the past tense, the subordinate subjunctive verb must remain in the present form (e.g., Azt akartam, hogy jöjjön. 'I wanted him to come.').
Examples (6)
- Mondta, hogy jön.
He said that he was coming.
Word by Word: Said-he, that comes-he.
The indicative mood is used here because the main verb reports a factual statement.
- Mondta, hogy jöjjön.
He told him to come.
Word by Word: Said-he, that come-he(subjunctive).
The subjunctive mood is used here because the main verb acts as an indirect command.
- Akarom, hogy itt maradj.
I want you to stay here.
Word by Word: Want-I, that here stay-you(subjunctive).
Verbs of volition require the subjunctive in the subordinate clause when the subjects are different.
- Szeretnék itt maradni.
I would like to stay here.
Word by Word: Would-like-I here stay-to.
When the main clause and subordinate clause share the same subject, Hungarian uses the infinitive instead of a hogy-clause.
- Nem tudom, eljön-e.
I don't know whether he will come.
Word by Word: Not know-I, away-comes-whether.
Indirect yes/no questions use the -e particle. In standard prescriptive grammar, 'hogy' is omitted to avoid a pleonasm.
- Remélem, hogy nyerünk.
I hope that we win.
Word by Word: Hope-I, that win-we(indicative).
Unlike Romance languages, Hungarian uses the indicative mood after verbs of hoping and emotion.
Common Mistakes
Using an infinitive for different-subject desires or commands.
Akarom őt jönni.Akarom, hogy jöjjön.English speakers often try to translate 'I want him to come' literally using an infinitive. In Hungarian, if the subject of the main verb and the subordinate verb are different, you must use a 'hogy' clause with the subjunctive.
Using the subjunctive with verbs of emotion or hope.
Remélem, hogy nyerjünk.Remélem, hogy nyerünk.Learners familiar with Romance languages often mistakenly apply the subjunctive to verbs like 'hope' or 'regret'. Hungarian is 'indicative-heavy' and uses the indicative for these verbs.
Attempting to use a past tense form for the subjunctive in subordinate clauses.
Azt akartam, hogy elment.Azt akartam, hogy elmenjen.The subjunctive mood does not have a past tense in modern Hungarian. Even when the main verb is in the past tense (like 'akartam'), the subordinate verb must remain in the present subjunctive form.
How It Connects
Learn This First
To understand the choice between indicative and subjunctive moods in complements, a learner must first be comfortable with the basic 'hogy' (that) clause structure. They also need to understand the imperative-subjunctive verb forms (the -j marker and its variants) and understand which specific matrix verbs (like those expressing desire, command, or necessity) require the subjunctive rather than the indicative.
Related Patterns
- hogy (tárgyi mellékmondat)That-Clauses
Provides the foundational structure for subordinate clauses introduced by 'hogy'.
Level 3 - -jImperative and Subjunctive
Explains the morphological formation of the subjunctive mood required in these clauses.
Level 2 - hogy (célhatározói mellékmondat)Purpose Clauses
A specific type of 'hogy' clause that universally requires the subjunctive mood.
Level 3 - Sibilant Assimilation in Verbs
Explains the mandatory consonant mutations that occur when adding the subjunctive -j suffix to certain verb stems.
Level 2