Deep Subordination
In Hungarian, you can pull a focus or question word out of a subordinate hogy-clause and place it directly into the main clause.
How It Works
When building complex sentences, Hungarian allows you to extract an element from the embedded clause and move it to the main clause's focus or topic position. Crucially, if it moves to the focus position, the extracted word must land immediately before the main verb. This is only possible with a specific, limited class of verbs known as 'bridge verbs' (e.g., mond, gondol, akar, hisz, tud).
1. The Anticipatory Pronoun and Island Constraint: The main clause often contains a pronoun (like azt) that points to the hogy-clause. However, to extract a word into the main clause, this anticipatory pronoun must be dropped. Its presence turns the hogy-clause into an island that blocks extraction.
2. Definiteness Override: A hogy-clause acts as a 3rd-person definite accusative object, so the main verb usually takes the definite conjugation. In the accusative-agreement pattern, the main verb instead agrees with the extracted word. This is not the only attested pattern: some constructions retain agreement with the clause. For example, extracting an indefinite word like kit forces the indefinite conjugation (Kit akarsz, hogy meghívjak? = 'Who do you want me to invite?'). If the extracted word is not accusative (e.g., kivel), the verb remains definite because Hungarian verbs only agree with accusative objects, so the matrix verb defaults to agreeing with the hogy-clause.
3. Case Switch (Focus Raising): When extracting the subject of the embedded clause, it often changes from nominative to accusative in the main clause. This also forces the indefinite conjugation on the main verb if the extracted subject becomes an indefinite accusative object (e.g., Kit akarsz, hogy nyerjen? = 'Who do you want to win?').
4. First- and Second-Person Agreement: Extracting a 2nd-person pronoun triggers the specific -lak/-lek suffix on the matrix verb, which is a crucial proof of the definiteness override (e.g., Téged akarlak, hogy eljöjj. = 'I want YOU to come.').
5. Subjunctive Mood: If the main verb expresses a wish or request, the embedded verb must be in the subjunctive mood.
Do not confuse this with wh-scope marking, where a dummy mit is used in the main clause while the actual question word stays in the embedded clause (Mit gondolsz, kivel találkoztam? = 'Who do you think I met?'). Both are natural, but true extraction integrates the word directly into the main clause's structure.
Case-Retaining Alternative: A fronted embedded subject can remain nominative, particularly as a contrastive topic: János mondtad, hogy jön a partira (Of János, you said that he would come to the party). Compare accusative Jánost mondtad, hogy jön a partira. Acceptance and preferred readings vary across speakers; do not mechanically change every extracted subject to accusative. With a retained anticipatory azt, the clause elaborates that pronoun instead of directly filling the matrix argument slot; this creates the structural boundary responsible for the extraction restriction in the construction taught here.
Agreement Variation: Both Két almát mondtad, hogy vettél and Két almát mondtál, hogy vettél are documented: the definite mondtad agrees with the clause, while indefinite mondtál corresponds to the fronted indefinite object. Learn the accusative-agreement pattern without treating every alternative as an error.
Examples (4)
- Kivel gondolod, hogy találkoztam?
Who do you think I met?
Word by Word: With-whom think-DEF.2SG that met-IND.1SG?
The instrumental word 'kivel' is extracted. Because it is not accusative, the main verb 'gondolod' remains in the definite conjugation, agreeing with the hogy-clause.
- Kit akarsz, hogy meghívjak?
Who do you want me to invite?
Word by Word: Who-ACC want-INDEF.2SG that invite-SUBJ.1SG?
The extracted 'kit' is accusative and indefinite. This overrides the hogy-clause's definiteness, forcing the main verb 'akarsz' into the indefinite conjugation. The embedded verb is subjunctive.
- Számítok arra, hogy időben érkezel.
I am counting on you arriving on time.
Word by Word: Count-INDEF.1SG that-SUBL that time-in arrive-IND.2SG.
The anticipatory pronoun 'arra' takes the sublative case (-ra/-re) because it is governed by the matrix verb 'számít'.
- Melyik könyvet mondtad, hogy elolvastad?
Which book did you say that you read?
Word by Word: Which book-ACC said-DEF.2SG that read-DEF.2SG?
The extracted phrase 'melyik könyvet' is definite and accusative, so the main verb 'mondtad' correctly stays in the definite conjugation.
Common Mistakes
Using the accusative 'azt' instead of the specific oblique case governed by the main verb.
Félek azt, hogy elkésünk.Félek attól, hogy elkésünk.The verb 'fél' (to be afraid) governs the ablative case (-tól/-től). Therefore, the anticipatory pronoun must be 'attól', not the default accusative 'azt'.
Keeping an overt anticipatory azt inside the extraction construction.
Kivel gondolod azt, hogy találkoztam?Kivel gondolod, hogy találkoztam?On the intended reading, kivel is the partner of the embedded meeting. Omit the clause-associate azt when fronting that argument into this matrix construction.
How It Connects
Learn This First
Deep subordination in Hungarian involves complex structures where a single element (like a relative pronoun or a focused noun) relates to a verb several clauses deep. To become confident with this, learners must understand how basic complement and relative clauses are formed, how case government works across these boundaries, and how word order (specifically verbal prefix placement) shifts in complex predicates.
- hogy (tárgyi mellékmondat)That-Clauses
Deep subordination involves nesting multiple 'hogy' (that) clauses, which requires a firm grasp of basic complementation.
Level 3 - Declined Relative Pronouns
Long-distance dependencies often involve relative pronouns that must agree with the case government of a verb deep within a nested clause.
Level 3 - Prefix Position with Infinitival Predicates
Understanding how verbal prefixes move across clause boundaries or auxiliary structures is essential for tracking information structure in complex sentences.
Level 5
Related Patterns
- Definiteness across Clauses
Understanding how definiteness works across clauses is essential for knowing when extraction overrides the main verb's conjugation.
Level 4 - Verb Government
The anticipatory pronoun in the main clause must take the specific case governed by the main verb.
Level 5 - -jImperative and Subjunctive
When the main verb expresses volition (like akar), the embedded verb in the hogy-clause must take the subjunctive mood.
Level 2
Learn Next
Patterns that build on this one.