Two Kinds of Modal Meaning
A modal verb can talk about how likely something is, or about duty and permission.
How It Works
Modal verbs do two jobs:
- They say how likely something is: Han må vere heime no, for lyset er på.
- They say what someone must, may or should do: Du må gå no.
| Verb | How likely | Duty or permission |
|---|---|---|
| må | Han må vere heime. (surely) | Du må gå. (have to) |
| kan | Det kan regne. (possibly) | Du kan låne bilen. (may) |
| bør | Bussen bør vere her snart. (expected) | Du bør kvile. (advice) |
| skal | Ho skal vere flink. (people say) | Du skal svare. (are to) |
Some hints help. The likely meaning is common with vere and with ha and a participle: Ho må ha gløymt det is a guess. The duty meaning is common with a person who can act and a verb of doing.
In the perfect the two meanings take different shapes:
- a guess about the past: Han må ha vore heime.
- a duty in the past: Han har måtta vere heime.
Examples (5)
- Han må vere heime no, for lyset er på.
He must be home now, because the light is on.
Må is a guess based on the light.
- Du må gå no, elles kjem du for seint.
You have to go now, or you will be late.
Må tells someone what they have to do.
- Det kan regne i morgon.
It may rain tomorrow.
Kan says that rain is possible.
- Du kan låne bilen min i kveld.
You can borrow my car tonight.
Kan gives permission.
- Bussen bør vere her om fem minutt.
The bus should be here in five minutes.
Bør says what the speaker expects.
Common Mistakes
Using the perfect of må for a guess.
Han har måtta vere heime i går.Han må ha vore heime i går.Har måtta means he had to stay home. A guess about the past uses må ha.
How It Connects
Learn This First
The two kinds of modal meaning are clearest once learners know the guessing use of må ha and kan ha.