〜こそすれ
May...but
Used to say 'A may happen, but B definitely won't.' It strongly denies a negative alternative by affirming a positive or neutral one.
How It Works
This pattern is a remnant of classical Japanese grammar, specifically the rule of 係り結び(かかりむすび). Under this rule, the emphatic particle こそ forces the verb at the end of the clause into its realis form(已然形、いぜんけい). This explains exactly why する becomes すれ, ある becomes あれ, and なる becomes なれ. It is highly formal(硬い)and is typically found in literature, editorials, or formal speeches. It translates to 'I may do A, but I certainly don't do B' or 'A, but definitely not B.'
1. Structure:
- Verbs: Use the ます-stem + こそすれ + [Negative Clause] (e.g., 増え(ふえ)こそすれ、減る(へる)ことはない - It may increase, but it will never decrease).
- Suru-Nouns: Use the action/emotion noun + こそすれ + [Negative Clause] (e.g., 感謝(かんしゃ)こそすれ、恨む(うらむ)ことはない - I may feel grateful, but I would never hold a grudge). Note that you can also apply the standard verb rule to suru-verbs, resulting in Noun + しこそすれ (e.g., 感謝しこそすれ).
2. Nuance & Usage Rules:
The speaker uses this to correct a potential misunderstanding or to state a firm conviction. By saying 'A happens,' they are setting the stage to say 'but B (the opposite) absolutely does not.' The words used in the two clauses are almost always direct antonyms or highly contrasting pairs (e.g., 増える vs. 減る, 感謝 vs. 恨む). While the subject of both the first and second clauses is usually the same, they can differ (e.g., 雨が降りこそすれ、雪が降ることはない). Additionally, the pattern usually pairs with strong negative endings in the second clause, such as 〜ことはない, 〜はずがない, or 〜絶対にない.
3. Action vs. State:
It is important to distinguish this from 〜こそあれ. The distinction is based on the underlying verb: use 〜こそすれ when the meaning is 'to do X' (Xはするが), and 〜こそあれ when the meaning is 'X exists' (Xはあるが). Action nouns can take 〜こそあれ if the focus is on existence (e.g., 苦労(くろう)こそあれ、...).
Furthermore, unlike 〜こそすれ, 〜こそあれ does not require a negative clause in the second half and is frequently followed by a positive statement (e.g., 苦労こそあれ、子育ては楽しいものです - There may be hardships, but raising children is fun). When using 〜こそあれ with adjectives, い-adjectives take the く-form (e.g., 高くこそあれ - It may be expensive, but...) and な-adjectives take で (e.g., 便利でこそあれ - It may be convenient, but...). Regular nouns can also take でこそあれ to express state or identity (e.g., 冗談(じょうだん)でこそあれ - It may be a joke, but...). For changes in state (becoming something), 〜こそなれ is used, which attaches to Noun + に or the に form of な-adjectives (e.g., プラスにこそなれ、マイナスにはならない - It may become a plus, but it will never become a minus).
Examples (3)
- 白髪は増えこそすれ、減ることはない。
White hairs may increase, but they certainly never decrease.
Word by Word: White hair (topic) increase (emphasis), decrease (thing) is not.
Uses the stem of 増える(ふえる - to increase) to emphasize that only an increase is possible, never a decrease.
- 私は彼を尊敬こそすれ、見下したことなど一度もありません。
I respect him; I have never once looked down on him.
Word by Word: I (topic) him (object) respect (emphasis), looked down on (thing) etc. even once there is not.
Uses the noun 尊敬(そんけい - respect) to clarify that the speaker's feelings are purely respectful and the opposite (looking down on him) is impossible.
- その法案は国民の生活を圧迫こそすれ、豊かにするとは思えない。
That bill will only pressure the lives of the citizens; I don't believe it will make them prosperous.
Word by Word: That bill (topic) citizens' lives (object) pressure (emphasis), make prosperous (quotation) think cannot.
Uses 圧迫(あっぱく - pressure/oppression) to argue that the bill's only effect is negative, denying any positive outcome.
Common Mistakes
Ending the sentence with a positive statement.
この薬は飲みこそすれ、すぐ治る。この薬は飲みこそすれ、すぐ治るわけではない。The second clause of 〜こそすれ must be negative. You cannot use it to simply connect two positive actions; it must deny the second part.
Using the dictionary form instead of the stem.
増えるこそすれ、減らない。増えこそすれ、減らない。You must use the ます-stem (連用形) of the verb before こそすれ.
How It Connects
Learn This First
〜こそすれ is a formal expression used to emphasize a contrast. It literally means 'While [A] is certainly true, [B] is definitely not.' It requires knowledge of the emphatic particle 'こそ' and the literary conjugation of the verb 'する' (すれ).
- Written Continuative
The 'すれ' in 'こそすれ' is the classical/literary continuative (izenkei) form of the verb 'する', which is a core component of this formal grammar structure.
Level 3 - けど/けれどもBut/although
This pattern functions as a formal contrastive marker (A but B), so a solid grasp of basic contrastive conjunctions is necessary to understand its purpose.
Level 2
Related Patterns
- 〜こそあれMay Exist but
The 'existence' version of this pattern. While 〜こそすれ means 'to do X', 〜こそあれ means 'X exists' (and can be used with action nouns). Unlike 〜こそすれ, it does not require a negative clause in the second half.
Level 5 - ことはないNo Need To/never
Often used in the second clause of 〜こそすれ to complete the 'definitely not' meaning.
Level 3 - 〜ないまでもEven if Not
Another formal contrastive pattern meaning 'even if it doesn't reach the level of A, at least B'.
Level 4 - なるTo Become
When describing a change in state (e.g., 'it will become a plus'), 〜こそなれ is used instead of 〜こそすれ.
Level 1