唔知 + Question Word
Indirect Question
The pattern 唔知 (m4 zi1) + [Question Word] allows you to embed a question inside a statement. Unlike English, the word order of the question does not change.
How It Works
When you want to express uncertainty or report that you don't know a specific piece of information, you use 唔知 (m4 zi1) followed by the question clause. Note that 唔知 is a common contraction of the more formal full form 唔知道 (m4 zi1 dou6, often pronounced with a changed tone as dou3 in colloquial speech).
Key features of this pattern:
- Word Order: The word order remains identical to a direct question. For example, 'Who is he?' is 佢係邊個? (keoi5 hai6 bin1 go3?). 'I don't know who he is' is 我唔知佢係邊個 (ngo5 m4 zi1 keoi5 hai6 bin1 go3).
- Subject Dropping: It is highly natural in Cantonese to omit the subject pronoun. Instead of explicitly saying 我唔知 (ngo5 m4 zi1), you can start a sentence directly with 唔知 (m4 zi1).
- 唔知 vs. 唔識: Remember that 唔知 (m4 zi1) is used for facts and information. If you want to say you don't know a person (as an acquaintance), a language, or how to do a skill, you use 唔識 (m4 sik1). However, if you are talking about knowing someone's identity (a fact), you still use 唔知 (e.g., 我唔知佢係邊個 - ngo5 m4 zi1 keoi5 hai6 bin1 go3, 'I don't know who he is').
- Particle Rules: In direct questions, we often use the particle 呀 (aa3). In an indirect question statement, this inner particle is usually dropped. However, the particle 呢 (ne1) is frequently kept or added to the end of the indirect question to soften the statement or express wondering. If the entire sentence is a question (e.g., 'Do you know...?'), you can use a sentence-final particle for the main clause, though it is optional if the main clause uses a V-not-V structure.
- The 'If/Whether' Shortcut: To say 'I don't know if...', you can use the V-not-V structure, or the universal shortcut 係咪 (hai6 mai6) before the verb.
- Alternative Questions: To say 'I don't know if A or B', use 定係 (ding6 hai6) between the choices.
- The Dilemma Pattern: A very common structure is 唔知 + verb/question word combination + 好 (hou2). This expresses a dilemma, meaning 'I don't know what is best to do.' The verb's position depends on the question word. For adverbs like 點 (dim2), the verb comes after (e.g., 唔知點算好 - m4 zi1 dim2 syun3 hou2, 'I don't know what to do'). For objects or locations, the verb comes before the question word (e.g., 唔知食咩好 - m4 zi1 sik6 me1 hou2, 'I don't know what to eat').
- Aspect Markers: Aspect markers like 咗 (zo2) remain attached to the verb inside the question clause, not to 唔知. For example, 我唔知佢買咗咩 (ngo5 m4 zi1 keoi5 maai5 zo2 me1) is correct, not 我唔知咗佢買咩.
- The 'For Some Reason' Phrase: The set phrase 唔知點解 (m4 zi1 dim2 gaai2) literally means 'I don't know why', but it frequently functions as a standalone adverbial phrase meaning 'for some unknown reason' (e.g., 唔知點解佢好嬲 - m4 zi1 dim2 gaai2 keoi5 hou2 nau1, 'For some reason, he is very angry').
- Expressing Wonder: Adding the particle 呢 (ne1) to the end of an '唔知' sentence is the standard Cantonese equivalent of the English phrase 'I wonder...'. This is the direct translation learners should use when they want to express wondering or thinking out loud.
- The 'So/Very' Idiom: A very common idiomatic use is 唔知幾 (m4 zi1 gei2) + Adjective. Despite containing 'not know', this actually means 'so' or 'very'. For example, 唔知幾好 (m4 zi1 gei2 hou2) means 'so good'.
- The '都' Emphasizer: To express total cluelessness or exasperation, you can add 都 (dou1) before 唔知. For example, 我都唔知佢講乜! (ngo5 dou1 m4 zi1 keoi5 gong2 mat1! - 'I have absolutely no idea what he is saying!').
Examples (6)
- 我唔知佢係邊個。
I don't know who he is.
Word by Word: I not know he is who.
The question word 邊個 (bin1 go3) stays at the end of the sentence, just like in a direct question.
- 我唔知佢幾時返嚟。
I don't know when he is coming back.
Word by Word: I not know he when return come.
The question word 幾時 (gei2 si4) stays after the subject.
- 我唔知佢係咪去行山。
I don't know if he is going hiking.
Word by Word: I not know he is-not-is go walk mountain.
You can use 係咪 (hai6 mai6) as a shortcut for 'if/whether' before the verb.
- 我唔知佢想飲茶定係飲咖啡。
I don't know if he wants to drink tea or coffee.
Word by Word: I not know he want drink tea or drink coffee.
Inside an indirect question, 'or' must be translated as 定係 (ding6 hai6).
- 唔知佢去咗邊度呢?
I wonder where he went.
Word by Word: Not know he go [perfective] where [wonder]?
Adding the particle 呢 (ne1) to an 唔知 structure expresses a sense of 'wondering'.
- 呢間餐廳唔知幾好食呀!
This restaurant is so delicious!
Word by Word: This [classifier] restaurant not know how good eat [particle]!
When 唔知 is followed by 幾 (gei2) and an adjective, it functions as an intensifier meaning 'so' or 'very'.
Common Mistakes
Changing the word order to match English.
我唔知邊個佢係。我唔知佢係邊個。In Cantonese, question words do not move to the front of the clause. They stay 'in-situ' (in place) exactly where they would be in a statement.
Attaching aspect markers directly to '唔知'.
我唔知咗佢買咩。我唔知佢買咗咩。Aspect markers like 咗 (zo2) must attach to the action verb inside the question clause, not to 唔知 (m4 zi1).
Adding the softening particle 呀 (aa3) after 唔知 and a question word.
Different Meaning我唔知佢去邊度呀。我唔知佢去邊度。我唔知佢去邊度呀 is natural: the final 呀 (aa3) softens the statement. The plain sentence without it is the neutral form. If you are asking someone else with a V-not-V structure (like '你知唔知...?'), a final particle is optional.
How It Connects
Learn This First
To understand indirect questions in Cantonese, a learner needs to know how to negate the verb 'to know' and be familiar with the 'wh-in-situ' property, where question words like 'where' or 'who' stay in their normal statement positions even when embedded in a larger sentence.
- Question Words Stay In Place
The learner must understand that Cantonese question words remain in their original grammatical position rather than moving to the front of the sentence.
Level 1 - 知Know That
The verb 'to know' is the core matrix verb used to introduce the indirect question clause.
Level 2 - 唔Not (General Negation)
Basic negation is required to form the 'don't know' (唔知) part of the expression.
Level 1
Related Patterns
- 係咪/係唔係Is It the Case That …?
A common way to introduce an 'if/whether' indirect question regardless of the main verb.
Level 1 - 呢 (ne1)And What About...?
Used at the end of these structures to change 'I don't know' into 'I wonder'.
Level 1 - V唔VVerb-not-verb Question
The standard structure used within the indirect clause to express 'whether or not'.
Level 1 - 定/定係Or (In Questions)
The required word for 'or' when expressing uncertainty between two options.
Level 2 - Leaving the particle off
Explains that while the inner question's particle is dropped, the outer sentence still follows normal particle rules.
Level 2