Case-Like Postpositions
In Hungarian, spatial, temporal, and abstract relations are expressed through a continuum of forms. Case-like postpositions (e.g., alatt 'under', mellett 'beside', miatt 'because of') sit between independent nouns and bound case suffixes. They function syntactically like cases but remain separate words.
How It Works
Hungarian postpositions have grammaticalized from independent nouns (often body parts or spatial concepts) into relational markers. Case-like postpositions represent an intermediate stage in this process.
Directional Triplets:
Many spatial postpositions form a three-way directional triplet indicating movement towards, stationary position, and movement away from. For example: mellé (to beside), mellett (stationary beside), and mellől (away from beside).
With Nouns:
Case-like postpositions follow a morphologically unmarked (nominative) noun. They are written as separate words and do not change their vowels to match the noun.
Example: a ház mellett (beside the house) — not *a ház-mallatt.
With Pronouns:
Because these postpositions historically meant things like "the side of" or "the space under," they behave like possessed objects. Case-like postpositions cannot follow a bare independent pronoun (e.g., én mellett is ungrammatical). Instead, they take singular or plural possessive suffixes directly. These suffixes undergo vowel harmony to match the postposition's own vowels.
Example: alattam (under me) vs. mögöttem (behind me); mellettem (beside me), nélkülük (without them).
The independent pronoun is usually dropped (pro-drop), but it can optionally precede this suffixed form for contrastive emphasis. When this happens, the pronoun and the suffixed postposition are written as a single word (e.g., énmellettem 'beside ME'). Note that for the third-person plural pronoun ők, the plural -k is dropped when forming this emphatic word (e.g., őmellettük, not *őkmellettük).
With Demonstratives:
When using demonstratives (ez or az) to modify a noun, the postposition must be duplicated after both the demonstrative and the noun to show agreement. Crucially, the definite article (a or az) is strictly required between the demonstrative phrase and the noun phrase. Prescriptively, the final z of the singular demonstrative drops before consonant-initial postpositions. This applies to both ez (e.g., e mellett a ház mellett 'beside this house') and az (e.g., a mögött az épület mögött 'behind that building'). In colloquial speech, native speakers frequently keep the z (e.g., ez mellett a ház mellett). Before vowel-initial postpositions, the z is always kept (e.g., ez alatt a ház alatt 'under this house'). With plural demonstratives, the plural marker is added before the duplicated postposition, and the final consonant is not dropped because the plural suffix starts with a vowel (e.g., ezek mellett a házak mellett 'beside these houses'). Note that when the demonstrative + postposition is used independently (not modifying a noun), it is written as a single word (e.g., emellett 'besides this', ezalatt 'during this').
Distinguishing from Other Forms:
- True Case Suffixes: Have completed grammaticalization. They are bound to the noun, written as one word, and strictly obey vowel harmony (e.g., -ban/-ben).
- Case-Assigning Postpositions: Require the preceding noun to take a specific oblique case suffix (e.g., a ház-on kívül 'outside the house', requiring the superessive -n). Case-like postpositions take a bare noun. When used with pronouns, the personal suffix attaches to the required case suffix, not the postposition itself (e.g., velem együtt 'together with me', not *együttem). With demonstratives, the postposition is not duplicated; the demonstrative just takes the matching case suffix (e.g., ezzel a fiúval együtt 'together with this boy').
Examples (5)
- A macska az asztal alatt alszik.
The cat is sleeping under the table.
Word by Word: The cat the table under sleeps.
The postposition 'alatt' follows the bare nominative noun 'asztal' and is written as a separate word.
- A szüleim miatt költöztem Budapestre.
I moved to Budapest because of my parents.
Word by Word: The parents-my because-of moved-I Budapest-onto.
'Miatt' is a case-like postposition following the nominative noun 'szüleim'.
- Elmentek a moziba nélkülem.
They went to the cinema without me.
Word by Word: Away-went-they the cinema-into without-me.
The postposition 'nélkül' takes the 1st-person singular possessive suffix '-em' to mean 'without me'. The pronoun 'én' is dropped.
- A ház mellett van egy nagy fa.
There is a big tree beside the house.
Word by Word: The house beside is a big tree.
'Mellett' does not undergo vowel harmony to match the front-vowel noun 'ház'.
- E mellett a ház mellett van egy szép kert.
There is a beautiful garden beside this house.
Word by Word: This beside the house beside is a beautiful garden.
When modifying a noun with a demonstrative, the postposition 'mellett' is duplicated, the 'z' in 'ez' drops before the consonant, and the definite article 'a' is strictly required before the noun.
Common Mistakes
Using uninflected postpositions with nominative pronouns.
Elmentek a moziba én nélkül.Elmentek a moziba nélkülem.English speakers often try to translate literally by placing a pronoun before the postposition. In Hungarian, case-like postpositions must be inflected with possessive suffixes when referring to pronouns.
Adding the accusative case to the noun before a case-like postposition.
A házat mellett van egy fa.A ház mellett van egy fa.Case-like postpositions require a bare nominative noun, not an accusative noun.
How It Connects
Learn This First
To understand postposition-to-case grammaticalization, a learner must first be comfortable with standard Hungarian postpositions and their syntactic behavior. This includes how they follow nouns and how they take personal suffixes (like 'alattam'). Understanding the structural difference between a free-standing postposition and a bound case suffix is necessary to recognize the historical and functional continuum between them.
- Inflected Postpositions
The ability of postpositions to take personal endings is a key stage in their grammaticalization into bound morphemes.
Level 3 - Order and Limits of Noun Suffixes
Knowledge of how suffixes are ordered and the limits of noun inflection helps in identifying when a postposition has transitioned into a bound case suffix.
Level 3
Related Patterns
- Noun + -n + PostpositionPostpositions After Superessive
Contrasts with case-like postpositions by showing postpositions that require the preceding noun to take a specific case suffix.
Level 3 - Vowel Harmony
Understanding vowel harmony is crucial to recognizing that case-like postpositions, unlike true case suffixes, do not harmonize with the noun.
Level 1