attendu que

Whereas with Attendu Que

Level 6

Attendu que is a highly formal conjunctive locution used in French legal and administrative writing. It introduces the facts or legal principles (motifs) that justify a court's ruling. In English, it is most often translated as 'whereas' or 'considering that.' It serves as a formal synonym for 'vu que', 'puisque', or 'étant donné que' in general administrative texts or contracts.

How It Works

1. Legal Function and Structure
In traditional French jurisprudence, a judgment was often written as one long sentence. The ruling begins with the Visa, a citation of the law being applied, introduced by Vu (e.g., Vu l'article 1382...). This is followed by the Motifs (reasons), where paragraphs generally begin with Attendu que (capitalized) and end with a semicolon (;). However, if a single line of reasoning spans multiple paragraphs, the subsequent paragraphs begin simply with Que... to avoid repetition. The final decision follows a phrase like 'Par ces motifs.'

2. Prepositional Usage
Beyond the conjunctional form, attendu can function as a preposition followed directly by a noun phrase, meaning 'in view of' or 'given.' For example: Attendu l'urgence de la situation... (Given the urgency of the situation...). In this usage, it remains strictly invariable and does not agree in gender or number with the noun. For instance, you must write Attendu les circonstances... (Given the circumstances...) and never Attendues les circonstances....

3. Mood and Grammar
Even though the verb attendre usually triggers the subjunctive when expressing a wait (e.g., J'attends qu'il vienne), the locution attendu que always takes the indicative. This is because it states a fact or a legal reality that is being taken into consideration.

4. Register and Modern Usage
This expression is restricted to the style soutenu (formal register). You will find it in court rulings, administrative resolutions, and formal contracts. Note: The French high courts have recently modernized their drafting to make law more accessible. The Conseil constitutionnel pioneered this change in 2016, followed by the Conseil d'État in 2018. The Cour de cassation, after initiating its reflection in 2014, adopted a 'direct style' in 2019. Instead of repeating the phrase every paragraph, the Conseil d'État now uses a single overarching phrase ('Considérant ce qui suit :'), while the Cour de cassation uses plain headings like 'Examen des moyens'. Though replaced in modern drafting, attendu que remains essential for reading historical case law.

5. Attendu que vs. Considérant que
While both mean 'whereas,' they traditionally had different primary usages, though the distinction was not absolute:

  • Attendu que: Primarily used by the highest judicial court (the Cour de cassation).
  • Considérant que: Used by administrative courts (like the Conseil d'État), the Conseil constitutionnel, and historically by lower civil courts.

6. The Structural Pivot: Mais attendu que
A highly famous and critical structural pivot in French case law is Mais attendu que. It is used by the Cour de cassation to introduce the Supreme Court's own counter-reasoning, effectively rejecting the arguments presented by the appellant.

7. Key Concepts and Synonyms
Because of the repetitive use of this conjunction in legal drafting, un attendu became a standalone noun meaning a 'paragraph' or 'recital' in a judgment. In legal theory, an attendu de principe is a specific paragraph where the court defines a general rule of law. While attendu que is highly specialized, you can use more common causal conjunctions like étant donné que, vu que, or puisque in formal but non-legal writing to express similar logic.

Examples (5)

  1. Attendu que le demandeur n'apporte pas la preuve du préjudice allégué, la cour rejette la demande.

    Whereas the plaintiff does not provide proof of the alleged harm, the court rejects the claim.

    Word by Word: Considering that the plaintiff not brings not the proof of the harm alleged, the court rejects the request.

    Here, 'attendu que' introduces the legal reason (lack of proof) that leads to the court's final decision (rejection).

  2. Attendu que la loi dispose que nul n'est censé ignorer la loi ;

    Considering that the law stipulates that no one is supposed to be ignorant of the law;

    Word by Word: Considering that the law disposes that no one is supposed to ignore the law;

    This demonstrates a classic legal maxim introduced by the formal 'attendu que' structure.

  3. Attendu qu'il résulte des pièces du dossier que le consentement a été vicié ;

    Given that it appears from the case file that consent was flawed;

    Word by Word: Considering that it results from the pieces of the file that the consent has been flawed;

    Note the use of the indicative 'résulte' and 'a été' following the conjunction.

  4. Attendu que le contrat est valide, les parties doivent respecter leurs engagements.

    Whereas the contract is valid, the parties must respect their commitments.

    Word by Word: Considering that the contract is valid, the parties must respect their commitments.

    In a formal contract or legal summary, this establishes the validity of the document as the basis for obligation.

  5. Attendu les faits exposés, la cour déclare la demande irrecevable.

    Given the facts presented, the court declares the request inadmissible.

    Word by Word: Considering the facts exposed, the court declares the request inadmissible.

    Here, 'attendu' is used as a preposition followed directly by a noun phrase ('les faits exposés'), meaning 'given' or 'in view of'.

Common Mistakes

  • Using the subjunctive mood after 'attendu que'.

    Attendu que le contrat soit valide...
    Attendu que le contrat est valide...

    Learners often confuse this with the verb 'attendre que' (to wait until), which requires the subjunctive. In the legal locution, the indicative is mandatory.

  • Using 'attendu que' in casual conversation or standard essays.

    Attendu qu'il pleut, je prends mon parapluie.
    Puisqu'il pleut, je prends mon parapluie.

    Using 'attendu que' for everyday reasons sounds pompous or like a parody of a lawyer. Use puisque or vu que instead.

How It Connects

Tap a pattern to see what it builds on and what it leads to.

attendu queLevel 6Whereas with Attendu Que

Learn This First

To understand 'attendu que', a learner must first be comfortable with standard causal conjunctions and the concept of formal register shifts in French. It is a specialized legal term used to introduce justifications, functioning as a formal version of 'since' or 'given that'.

Words in This Pattern

attendu queattendu