咩 (me1)
Surprised or Disbelieving Question
When you hear something unexpected or hard to believe, add 咩 (me1) at the end of the sentence to ask 'Really?!' or 'Are you saying that...?' It is never neutral.
How It Works
What is 咩 (me1)?
The particle 咩 (me1) is one of Cantonese's most common sentence-final particles. It turns any clause or statement into a question filled with doubt, surprise, counter-expectation, or challenge.
Key Functions:
- Surprise or Disbelief: Translates roughly to 'Really?!' or 'Don't tell me...!' when reacting to surprising news.
- Counter-Expectation: Used when you assumed the opposite was true (e.g., assuming someone remembered, but learning they forgot).
- Rhetorical Challenge: Asking 'Are you seriously saying that?'
How to Use It:
Attach 咩 (me1) to the end of a statement, short response, or conversational fragment (e.g., 係咩? hai6 me1? - 'Is that so?'). It can also combine with other particles, such as in 嘅咩 (ge3 me1).
• Statement: 你唔記得 (nei5 m4 gei3 dak1 - You don't remember)
• Disbelieving Question: 你唔記得咩? (nei5 m4 gei3 dak1 me1? - You mean you don't remember?!)
Important Distinction:
Never use 咩 (me1) for a polite, neutral yes/no question. For neutral questions, use A-not-A forms or 係咪 (hai6 mai6). Using 咩 (me1) signals that you are reacting to unexpected information.
Examples (4)
- 你唔記得咩?
You mean you don't remember?
Word by Word: you not remember SFP
Adding 咩 (me1) shows the speaker assumed the listener remembered and is surprised by their forgetfulness.
- 今日係星期六咩?
Is today Saturday?!
Word by Word: today is Saturday SFP
The speaker thought today was Friday or another day and is surprised to hear it's Saturday.
- 佢話唔嚟咩?
Did he say he isn't coming?!
Word by Word: he say not come SFP
Expresses skepticism or shock upon hearing that someone isn't coming.
- 你唔食飯咩?
Are you saying you're not going to eat?!
Word by Word: you not eat rice SFP
Shows counter-expectation because the speaker expected the listener to eat.
Common Mistakes
Using 咩 (me1) when you want a neutral yes/no question (like Mandarin 嗎).
Different Meaning你去街咩?你去唔去街呀? / 你係咪去街呀?你去街咩 is a good sentence, but 咩 (me1) carries surprise or doubt: 'What, you are going out?' For a neutral question, use A-not-A or 係咪 (hai6 mai6).
Reading 你食咩 as a surprised question.
Different Meaning你食咩?你食飯咩?你食咩 is a good sentence meaning 'What are you eating?', where 咩 replaces the object (short for 乜嘢 mat1 je5). To express surprise about the action of eating, complete the clause with 食飯 and put particle 咩 (me1) at the end.
How It Connects
Learn This First
To understand '咩' (me1), you need to be familiar with how Cantonese uses sentence-final particles to change the tone of a statement. It is also helpful to understand basic question structures, as '咩' (me1) adds a layer of surprise or disbelief to a standard inquiry.
- Sentence-final particles
Understanding that Cantonese uses particles at the end of sentences to convey mood and grammatical function is essential for learning '咩' (me1).
Foundations - A particle's tone changes its feeling
The specific tone of '咩' (me1) is crucial to its meaning as a surprised or challenging question, distinguishing it from other particles.
Foundations - 係咪/係唔係Is It the Case That …?
Learners should first understand basic yes-no question structures before moving to more nuanced, challenging questions like those formed with '咩' (me1).
Level 1
Related Patterns
- 唔係...咩Isn't It the Case That
A rhetorical framing combining 唔係 (is not) with 咩 to challenge someone with 'Isn't it the case that...?'
Level 4 - 嘅咩 (ge3 me1)Is That Really So?
Combines the factual aspect particle 嘅 with 咩 to express strong doubt regarding an underlying fact.
Level 3 - 啩 (gwaa3)I Guess
While 咩 challenges a statement with a question, 啩 makes a hesitant guess ('I suppose / I guess').
Level 2 - 呀 (aa3)Neutral Softening Particle
Used for standard, softened, or neutral questions without the skepticism of 咩.
Level 1 - 乜嘢What
The interrogative pronoun for 'what', which often contracts phonetically to the word 咩.
Level 1 - 係咪Is It / Isn't It
Used for seeking confirmation or asking 'Is it true that...?' neutrally.
Level 1
Learn Next
Patterns that build on this one.