foi...que

Cleft Sentences with Foi Que

Level 5

The foi...que pattern (cleft sentence) is used to highlight a specific piece of information, often to contrast it with something else. It's like saying 'It was [X] that [did Y]' in English.

How It Works

In Portuguese, the oração clivada (cleft sentence) is a powerful tool for emphasis.

1. Structure and Agreement:
The basic formula is: [Ser] + [Focused Element] + que + [Rest of Sentence].
In standard grammar, when the focused element is the subject, the verb ser must agree with it in person and number. However, when focusing a direct object, modern descriptive grammars state that the invariable 3rd person singular is standard (e.g., Foi os livros que eu comprei), and the verb ser NEVER agrees in person with a direct object (e.g., Foi a nós que ele convidou, not Fomos a nós). The verb ser also typically matches the tense of the main verb. If the focused element is preceded by a preposition or is an adverb (e.g., Foi ontem que eles chegaram), ser remains invariable in the 3rd person singular. In everyday spoken Brazilian Portuguese, it is extremely common for ser to remain invariable in the 3rd person singular even with subject pronouns (e.g., Foi eu que fiz, Foi eles que ligaram). Warning: In formal writing and proficiency exams, this is considered a strict grammatical error for subjects; you must make the verb agree (e.g., Fui eu que fiz).
Examples:

  • Fui eu que fiz. (It was I who did it - subject focus).
  • Foi os livros que eu comprei. (It was the books that I bought - object focus).
  • Será ele que fará o discurso. (It will be him who will give the speech).
  • Foi com eles que eu falei. (It was with them that I spoke).

2. The Invariable "é que":
While ser often matches the tense of the main verb, it is very common to use é que as a fixed, unchanging emphatic particle (locução expletiva) regardless of the tense or subject. The syntax here is: [Focused Element] + é que + [Rest of Sentence].
Example: Eles é que fizeram o trabalho. (They were the ones who did the work). Because é que acts as an expletive particle, it can be entirely removed from the sentence without changing the core meaning or making it ungrammatical (e.g., Eles fizeram o trabalho).

3. Interrogative Use of "é que":
A crucial and highly natural use of this structure, especially in spoken and European Portuguese, is in questions. Adding é que after a question word adds emphasis and flow.
Example: Onde é que você mora? (Where [is it that] you live?)

4. What can be focused?

  • Subjects: Foi o João que ligou.
  • Objects: Foi um carro que ele comprou.
  • Adverbials: Foi em Paris que nos conhecemos.

5. Using "Quem":
When focusing on a person, you can replace que with quem. If the focused person is the subject of the embedded verb, the verb can either stay in the 3rd person singular or agree with the subject (both Fui eu quem fez and Fui eu quem fiz are correct). However, if the focused person is the object, the verb must agree with the actual subject of the clause (e.g., Foi a Maria quem nós vimos).

6. Prepositions:
If the embedded verb requires a preposition (like com or de), the preposition is placed before the focused element, leaving the relative pronoun que bare. For example, Gosto de você becomes Foi de você que eu gostei (not Foi você de que eu gostei). This rule also applies to the invariable é que structure: Com eles é que eu falei.

7. Pronoun Placement:
The word que acts as a trigger for proclisis, moving object pronouns before the verb: Foi ele que me deu o presente.

8. Pseudocleft Sentences (Orações pseudoclivadas):
A highly natural alternative to the standard cleft structure is the inverted pseudocleft sentence, which uses quem (for people) or o que (for things).
Examples:

  • Quem ligou foi o João. (The one who called was João).
  • O que ele comprou foi um carro. (What he bought was a car).

Examples (5)

  1. Foi a minha irmã que fez o bolo.

    It was my sister who made the cake.

    Word by Word: Was the my sister that made the cake.

    Here, the subject 'my sister' is emphasized to show she is the one responsible for the cake.

  2. Será o diretor que anunciará as novas regras.

    It will be the director who will announce the new rules.

    Word by Word: Will-be the director that will-announce the new rules.

    Notice how the verb 'ser' matches the future tense of the main action (anunciará) in a canonical cleft sentence.

  3. Onde é que vocês jantaram ontem?

    Where did you have dinner yesterday?

    Word by Word: Where is that you dined yesterday?

    The invariable 'é que' is frequently used after question words to make questions sound more natural and emphatic, especially in spoken Portuguese.

  4. Somos nós que vamos pagar a conta.

    It is us who are going to pay the bill.

    Word by Word: Are we that go to-pay the bill.

    In formal registers, the verb 'ser' agrees with the subject (Somos nós).

  5. Foi de você que eles estavam falando.

    It was about you that they were talking.

    Word by Word: Was of you that they were talking.

    Notice how the preposition 'de' stays with the focused pronoun 'você'.

Common Mistakes

  • Using 'onde' instead of 'que' inside the cleft frame.

    Foi em Lisboa onde eu nasci.
    Foi em Lisboa que eu nasci.

    Even when referring to places, the standard particle used in this specific focusing construction is 'que'. While 'quem' is valid for people, 'onde' is not used as the clivada particle.

  • Placing the object pronoun after the verb (enclisis) after 'que'.

    Foi ele que deu-me o livro.
    Foi ele que me deu o livro.

    The word 'que' attracts the pronoun to the position before the verb (proclisis).

  • Forgetting the preposition inside the frame.

    Foi a Maria que eu precisei de ajuda.
    Foi da Maria que eu precisei de ajuda.

    Since the verb 'precisar' requires the preposition 'de', it must appear with the focused element (da).

How It Connects

Tap a pattern to see what it builds on and what it leads to.

foi...queLevel 5Cleft Sentences with Foi Que

Learn This First

To learn cleft sentences (orações clivadas), you need to understand how the verb 'ser' (specifically in the past form 'foi') combines with the relative pronoun 'que' to create a frame for emphasis. This structure requires familiarity with past tense actions and how to connect clauses using 'que'.

Learn Next

Patterns that build on this one.

Words in This Pattern