Impersonal Evaluations

Level 3

In Hungarian, many common expressions like 'must', 'allowed', or 'like' don't use a standard subject. Instead, the person experiencing the state is put in the dative case (-nak/-nek), while the action itself is the grammatical subject.

How It Works

In English, we say 'I must go.' In Hungarian, the structure is more like 'To me, it is necessary to go.'

1. The Dative Participant
The person involved takes the dative suffix -nak/-nek. If using a pronoun, you use the dative forms: nekem, neked, neki, nekünk, nektek, nekik. These pronouns are often omitted because the personal infinitive endings (explained below) already indicate who the statement applies to.

2. Common Predicates
This pattern is required with:

  • Modals: kell (must/need), muszáj (must - stronger), szabad (allowed), lehet (possible), tilos (forbidden).
  • Evaluations: fontos (important), nehéz (difficult), jó (good).

Note: Verbs like tetszik (to like/please) and fáj (to hurt) also take dative experiencers. However, tetszik takes a noun subject (Nekem tetszik ez a könyv - I like this book), while fáj can take an infinitive action as its subject (e.g., Fáj látnom - It hurts me to see).

3. The Action (Infinitive)
When using modals like kell or szabad, the action is expressed with an infinitive.

  • General Statements: Use the plain -ni ending when no specific person is intended (e.g., Sokat kell aludni - One must sleep a lot).
  • Specific Subjects: When a specific person is involved, you can use either the plain infinitive or personal infinitive endings. While both forms are used (e.g., Jánosnak mennie kell and Jánosnak kell menni), the personal infinitive is the formal standard, whereas the plain infinitive is considered colloquial or casual. To form the personal infinitive, drop the -i from the -ni ending for the 1st and 2nd person and add possessive-style endings, using link vowels based on vowel harmony (e.g., olvasni → olvasnom). However, for the 3rd person singular and plural, the -i is retained (e.g., -nia/-nie, -niuk/-niük).

4. Tense and Negation
How you change the tense depends on the type of word used as the predicate:

  • Modal/Quasi-auxiliary verbs: Words like kell, lehet, and sikerül act as modal or quasi-auxiliary verbs and conjugate directly for tense (e.g., kellett - it was necessary, lehetett - it was possible).
  • Non-Verbs: Adjectives and nouns like szabad, tilos, muszáj, or fontos require the auxiliary van in the past (volt) or future (lesz). Example: Szabad volt menned (You were allowed to go).

For negation, place nem before the predicate. Crucial difference: nem kell means a lack of obligation ("don't have to"), whereas nem szabad or tilos expresses prohibition ("must not"). Example: Nem kell menned (You don't have to go) vs. Nem szabad menned (You must not go).

5. Word Order and Verbal Prefixes
In neutral sentences without prefixes, the infinitive often precedes the modal (e.g., Mennem kell), though the reverse is also common (Kell mennem). When an infinitive has a verbal prefix (like el- or meg-), the word order depends on the predicate used:

  • With kell, szabad, lehet: In affirmative sentences, the prefix jumps in front of the modal verb (e.g., El kell mennem - I must go away). In negative sentences, the negation word nem comes first, followed by the modal, and the prefix stays attached to the infinitive (e.g., Nem kell elmennem - I don't have to go away).
  • With muszáj and evaluative adjectives: Words like muszáj, fontos, or nehéz generally do not split the verbal prefix from the infinitive (e.g., Muszáj elmennem - I absolutely must go).

Examples (6)

  1. Nekem kell egy kávé.

    I need a coffee.

    Word by Word: To-me is-necessary a coffee.

    Here, 'kell' acts as 'need'. The person needing the coffee is in the dative (nekem).

  2. Péternek nem szabad dohányoznia.

    Peter is not allowed to smoke.

    Word by Word: To-Peter not allowed to-smoke-his.

    The person who is restricted (Peter) takes the -nak suffix, and the infinitive takes a personal ending (-nia).

  3. Nektek sikerült megérkeznetek?

    Did you all manage to arrive?

    Word by Word: To-you-all succeeded to-arrive-your-plural?

    The verb 'sikerül' (to succeed) requires the person to be in the dative case and the infinitive to have a personal ending.

  4. A gyerekeknek tetszik a játék.

    The children like the toy.

    Word by Word: To-the children pleases the toy.

    In Hungarian, the 'liker' is in the dative case, while the thing liked (a játék) is the nominative subject.

  5. Nekünk fontos a pontosság.

    Punctuality is important to us.

    Word by Word: To-us important the punctuality.

    Evaluative adjectives like 'fontos' use the dative to show who the evaluation applies to.

  6. Muszáj volt elmennem.

    I had to leave.

    Word by Word: Must was to-leave-my.

    'Muszáj' is a common modal meaning 'must'. In the past tense, we add 'volt'.

Common Mistakes

  • Using the nominative pronoun (Én, Te, etc.) instead of the dative.

    Én kell menni.
    Nekem kell mennem.

    In Hungarian, 'kell' cannot take a nominative subject pronoun like 'én'. You must use the dative 'nekem' or simply use the inflected infinitive 'mennem'.

  • Leaving the verbal prefix attached to the infinitive in affirmative modal sentences.

    Kell elmennem.
    El kell mennem.

    In a neutral affirmative sentence with a modal like 'kell', the verbal prefix splits from the infinitive and moves directly in front of the modal verb.

How It Connects

Tap a pattern to see what it builds on and what it leads to.

Impersonal EvaluationsLevel 3

Learn This First

To understand impersonal evaluations, you must first be comfortable with the dative case (-nak/-nek), as it identifies who the evaluation applies to. You also need to understand how Hungarian uses zero copulas for third-person statements and how infinitives function as the verbal complement of these expressions.

Words in This Pattern

-nak-nek