egon naiz / izan naiz
Having Been Somewhere
Parisen izan naiz (I have been to Paris, a visit). Parisen bi urte egon naiz (I have spent two years in Paris). Irakasle izan naiz (I have been a teacher). Gaixorik egon naiz (I have been ill).
How It Works
The forms. Both are nor verbs, so they use the present of izan as the auxiliary, like any present perfect: izan naiz, izan zara, izan da; egon naiz, egon zara, egon da. With izan, the participle and the auxiliary come from the same verb: izan naiz.
What someone has been: izan. Jobs, roles and identity take izan, just as in the present: Irakasle izan naiz (I have been a teacher). Alkatea izan da (She has been the mayor).
Where someone has been.
- izan for a visit, a trip or being at an event: Inoiz Parisen izan zara? (Have you ever been to Paris?) Gaur goizean bankuan izan naiz (I have been to the bank this morning).
- egon for a stay, often with a length of time: Hiru hilabete egon naiz Londresen (I have spent three months in London).
The line is soft. In the South many speakers also use egon for a visit, as in Inoiz Bilbon egon zara?, and both are correct. What never changes is that the place takes -n.
How someone has been: egon. Temporary states usually take egon, as in the present: Gaixorik egon naiz (I have been ill), Oso lanpetuta egon gara (We have been very busy). See Choosing izan or egon and states with -ta and -rik.
Examples (6)
- Inoiz Parisen izan zara?
Have you ever been to Paris?
izan for a visit. Inoiz Parisen egon zara? is also heard.
- Gaur goizean bankuan izan naiz.
I have been to the bank this morning.
- Hiru hilabete egon naiz Londresen.
I have spent three months in London.
egon stresses the stay and its length.
- Irakasle izan naiz, eta orain itzultzailea naiz.
I have been a teacher, and now I am a translator.
A job is what someone is, so it takes izan.
- Aste honetan gaixorik egon naiz.
I have been ill this week.
A temporary state takes egon.
- Gure lagunak Bilbon izan dira asteburuan.
Our friends have been in Bilbao this weekend.
Common Mistakes
Using egon for what someone has been.
Irakasle egon naiz.Irakasle izan naiz.A job or role is what someone is, so it takes izan, in the perfect as in the present.
Using the nork auxiliary.
Parisen izan dut.Parisen izan naiz.izan and egon are nor verbs, so their perfect uses naiz. izan dut means I have had.
How It Connects
Learn This First
This builds on izan and egon and the perfect.
Related Patterns
- izan: naiz / zara / daThe Verb Izan (To Be)
Serves both as the verb izan and as its auxiliary.
Level 1 - egon: nago / zaude / dagoThe Verb Egon (To Be Somewhere)
The present of egon, for where and how someone is now.
Level 1 - -nWhere: -n (In, At, On)
The ending the place takes with both verbs: Parisen, bankuan.
Level 1 - etorri izan daHave Done Before
Another use of izan for life experience, at a higher level.
Level 5